----- Original Message -----
Sent: Thursday, May 10, 2007 11:49
AM
Subject: [ARLIS-L] Art Auction
Information
Thanks to all who answered my
query--in some cases I still have your name and in others I don't so I'm not
attaching names to any of these. Enough people asked for the results that I
decided to post it here. Although the student's assignment is over, I'm sure
additional candidates will still be of interest to the list.
Original reference question:
I have to answer the following question for my Reference and
Information Services class: Which electronic database(s) should I search for a
comprehensive collection of the contents of art auction catalogs? (More than
one of you mentioned the question was badly worded & ambiguous. The
student is of the opinion this was on purpose so it would more closely
resemble a real reference question.)
Answer #1
To find out about the
*existence* of auction catalogs (i.e. bib level), I recommend students search
the online catalog of the Art Institute of Chicago. Their OPAC has a
special limit for auction catalogs in their collection. Another good OPAC is
the library of the Cleveland museum, I believe.
Answer #2
Two databases
that you could use to find the contents of art auction catalogs - that is, to
find what works of art were sold by which auction houses in which sales (which
allows you to find the catalogs) - are ArtNet and ArtFact.
A database you
could use to find out which libraries own copies of specific auction catalogs
is Scipio; another is called Lugt Online.
Answer #3
At our public library
[Sahara West Library, Las Vegas] we do not have the online equivalents of
Gordon's Print Price Annual (the bible when it comes to auction print prices);
Davenports (price guide--an immensely useful screening device: if the artist
is not listed in it than chances are you are going to have a very difficult
time elsewhere); and ADEC (ceased print publication but I recommend the online
product for patrons who want to pay--one of the more comprehensive sources in
my humble opinion).
We do have one
online subscription--p4A.com--that our patrons like because it covers both
antiques and collectibles plus selectively fine art. Here is a synopsis
of the product:
§
The www.p4aantiquesreference.com
reference database is distinguished by a number of unique characteristics not
found at any other place on the world wide web:
§ Every record in the database has at least one picture. You can really
tell if this is similar to the item you are researching.
§ Every record in the database is compiled by a human editor, not
digitally accumulated en masse.
§
Editors allow us to
have a highly personalized and custom approach to record development,
including such features as listing repeat sales of a specific item on the same
record and expanded literature citations.
§ Each record
is presented in a standardized format with description, provenance, condition,
dimensions, pre-sale estimates, price realized, date of sale and auction house
information as provided in the original sale catalogue.
§ Approximately twenty percent of the records in the database have an
individually researched reference note providing further information about the
item, information not found in the original catalogue entry. Other records
have market notes identifying the auction record price paid for that type of
material.
§
About fifty percent of the records in the
database have an individually written "auction note" providing specific
information about the auction environment in which that particular item was
sold.
§
p4A records are routinely annotated with
relevant post-sale information appearing in the trade press. No other
information source on the web can claim even one of these distinguishing
characteristics.
About 87% of all the
information in the www.p4aantiquesreference.com reference database is totally
unique to this site. A large portion of it has NEVER appeared anywhere else on
the web. Much of the remaining information is not web searchable using
standard web search engines. p4A is a truly unique, high value, low cost,
reference source for antiques, collectibles and fine arts.
Answer #4
I have created an Access database in which I have been indexing all the
auction catalogues we receive at Beverly Hills Public Library. We are
able to search the database for artists, media, bibliographies, etc., as well
as keep automatically updated and expanded bibliographies for the results of
the searches we perform. In other words, once I've searched the database
for 2007 catalogues covering the "Decorative Arts", I am able to print out the
results of the search that includes any catalogues subsequently received and
indexed using the term "decorative arts". We decided that we needed this
database because we wanted to be able to access the wealth of information in
the catalogues in our collection.
Edith L. Crowe | (408) 808-2037 | [log in to unmask]
Interim Head
of Collection Development
Art & Humanities Librarian & Coordinator
of Graduate Instruction
San Jose State University Library
(http://www.sjlibrary.org)
Corresponding Secretary of the Mythopoeic
Society (http://www.mythsoc.org)
__________________________________________________________________ Mail
submissions to [log in to unmask] For information about joining ARLIS/NA see:
http://www.arlisna.org/join.html Send administrative matters (file requests,
subscription requests, etc) to [log in to unmask] ARLIS-L Archives and
subscription maintenance: http://lsv.uky.edu/archives/arlis-l.html Questions
may be addressed to list owner (Judy Dyki) at:
[log in to unmask]
__________________________________________________________________
Mail submissions to