Arthur, I sent this to you yesterday, but am not sure it went thru. Thus, re-sent.

Arthur,  Gretchen also reread the H-S paper which elicited a comment to her from me as follows:     
"Arthur also recently reread the Hershey-Schoemaker paper, and found the strength of the reflection effect to be not as great as he remembered it. I would remind you that in the recurring trauma of journal peer review of the monetary modeling paper, all the data re reflection effect was eliminated. We indeed have a treasure trove of reflection effect data in the monetary sphere that (now, in a backwards fashion) supplements the significant reflection effect published in our framing paper. So, if anyone thought it was important, the monetary reflection effect could be resurrected and published. I say above "in a backwards fashion" because our interest always was to do "simple"  basic monetary problems first as a prelude to learning how then to apply findings to life expectancy problems."
       Considering your comment on the importance of H-S thoughts, would this idea seem attractive to you?    See you Saturday.   Lionel